As a person of Scottish, Cherokee, and African American descent who grew up in the poor and mostly Black part of Dallas Texas - I've been forced to confront race and racism from all sides at an early age. Some Black people don't like me because of my White mother or because I'm not dark enough or "black" enough. Some White people don't like me because I'm Black. Some White people only like me because they think I'm Hispanic at first. Some Hispanics like me...until they realize I'm Black. On and on it goes.
As I watched the events in Dallas Texas unfold last night and today (where five Dallas police officers died after gunmen systematically executed them during and after a Black Lives Matter rally in downtown), I can't help but wonder if those who support the Black Lives Matter movement really understand what it is they are advocating. All evidence seems to suggest that they don't. On the outside, BLM seems harmless and honorable enough. When you take a closer look, however, you will start to see some fundamental and alarming problems.
- The very name of the movement - Black Lives Matter.
- There is an ellipsis at the end of this movement's name - ...more than other lives.
I'm not saying that the ellipsis was intended, but it's there none the less. This is why you see people now adopting the hashtag #alllivesmatter. They do this because the movement has made them feel as though their lives do not matter. I understand that there is a growing problem with police violence in this country which disproportionately affects those in Black communities. I understand that Black lives matter. The name though, while seemingly trying to draw attention to the issues of police violence against Black people, also implies that other lives don't matter at all or at the very least not as much. The focus shouldn't be on race, but it is. This isn't helping the racism issue in this country. It's breeding a whole new generations of racist...on ALL sides.
Think about it this way - The
Traditionalist American Knights of the KKK state that they are a non-violent organization dedicated to the "preservation of the white race in the United States". They say they are non-violent; but as we all know, their very existence inspires hatred and violence. The fact that they self segregate and focus solely on the white race signals that other races are not important or valuable. This is the issue with identifying by race in a political or social movement. It seems harmless, or loyal, or in touch with one's ancestry; but it's not. Its divisive, destructive, and dangerous.
- The focus of the movement.
- According to the BLM website the focus is on "state violence" against Black people.
The word "violence" is found on the BLM Who We Are page six times. The focus is on violence executed by the "state". With such a focus on "violence", it was only a matter of time before the movement inspired violence. The BLM movement says it is "broadening the conversation"; when in fact it's narrowing the conversation to race and excluding non-black people from that conversation. You can't seek to stop race-based attacks on the Black community by alienating people of non-black heritage. This is exactly what BLM is currently doing. The message, the focus, and the execution ALL need to change.
- The organization of the movement.
- In interviews with those described as the founders of the BLM movement, it has been stated that BLM is a leaderless movement.
Here's the problem - A leaderless movement is also a movement that is unfocused, off-message, and subject to a dangerous evolution. We didn't achieve progress for Black people in America without leaders. This type of non-approach leaves the execution of this movement open to interpretation. As we saw in Dallas, some have now interpreted this as violence against police. I'm not saying that the killing of five Dallas police officers was sanctioned by BLM, but the movement bears some responsibility in that it refuses to clearly identify as "non-violent" and in fact, it's sole focus IS violence. It allows people from the community to decide for themselves how to resolve "state violence" - some, opting just to shoot back. Violence or focusing on violence is NOT the right approach. The BLM movement is in it's "toddler" period now and has done little in the way of fixing the problem of racism or violence in this country.
- The execution of the movement.
- The movement has"fired" upon the wrong targets too many times.
In December of last year, BLM disrupted air travel at an airport and shopping at a popular and busy mall. This is yet another example of the wrong focus and execution. A movement shouldn't seek to punish those who may have nothing to do with the plight of the Black community. These were people trying to see their families or buy gifts for loved ones. Seeking to disrupt everyday life is not the way to change the hearts and minds of this country. It reeks of selfishness and ill-will toward those who have nothing to do with "state violence". At political rallies, BLM shows up screaming or taking over stages in an effort to force people to listen. Screaming at people only alienates them further. Again, this is where leaders come in. They help people focus and stay on message; and to deliver that message in a way that is not only powerful, but poignant and better received.
The Bottom Line
Trying to force people to listen to your point of view, while systematically alienating those who you say you are trying to speak to is fucking foolish. It's time for everyone to stop hiding behind their race. It's time to stop pretending that pride in your heritage is the reason for your actions and behaviors. It's not. Your selfishness and belief that your life matters more than those of a different race because of a threat (either perceived or real) is the reason for your actions and behaviors. You can be proud without alienating those around you. You can honor your history without creating or contributing to a future soaked in violence, segregation, hatred, ignorance, and intolerance. We can all live together in love and peace...when we CHOOSE to do so. We can all move beyond racism once we stop breathing life into it with provocation, violence, screaming, anger, hatred, and retaliation.
White people, stop pretending like you're in danger of losing something. You're not. White Americans slaughtered Native Americans in order to lay claim to something that didn't belong to them. White Americans enslaved Africans and refused to treat them like humans. The only thing you're in danger of is perpetuating the cycle of ignorance that says you're superior to anyone. We aren't. We come from the same stock of people who murdered some and enslaved others. ENOUGH. Get your shit together and realize the worth of all human life whether you relate to them or not.
Black people, stop pretending like you arrived on a slave ship. You didn't. Stop saying you want and end to racism while simultaneously segregating yourselves. Stop screaming at people and learn to have a real conversation. Do the hard work that is required to really "broaden the conversation"; not just the easy work of preaching to the choir. Stop punishing the good White people of this country for shit the bad ones do. We don't honor our ancestors and those who fought for our freedoms by shitting all over their sacrifice with our selfishness and willful ignorance. We have JUST as must a part to play in eradicating racism as any White person living or dead.
Racism and discrimination of ALL kinds is defeated in the small moments in life. Talk to that co-worker who may be narrow-minded or sheltered. Show those passing you on the street the kindness they may not think you deserve. Conduct yourselves with the kind of honor that transcends your heritage. Stop being afraid to speak out against violent actions and words from your "own kind". Stop letting people of all colors get a free pass on hatred and ignorance. Speak up. Speak softly. Speak often. Speak from your heart. The war on race won't be won by force. It will be won when we decide that human life is THE most important resource on the planet.
